Carroll County, Ohio homeowners insurance
Updated
Typical ZIP in Carroll County: $1,139 a year (median of 10 ZIP codes, U.S. Treasury Federal Insurance Office, 2022 data).
Read more
The county average of the ZIP averages is $1,149. Premiums have risen since then and vary by home, insurer and coverage, so a quote for your home will differ.
What it costs in Carroll County
For comparison, the National Association of Insurance Commissioners put the Ohio statewide average at $1,116 a year in 2023. That is a different source and year, so the two figures are not directly comparable. Premiums have risen since then and vary by home, insurer and coverage, so a quote for your home will differ.
Insurers did not renew about 9 of every 1,000 homeowners policies in 2022 (Treasury).
What the Treasury data cover: homeowners policies from insurers that reported to the NAIC, by ZIP code, with ZIP codes that have few insurers or policies left out. They do not include flood coverage or state insurers of last resort, and they are not a quote. Source: Treasury FIO
Advertisement
Flood insurance in Carroll County
50 National Flood Insurance Program policies were in force in Carroll County as of November 11, 2026, averaging $1,080 a year in premium and $1,369 with federal fees (FEMA).
Most homeowners insurance does not cover flood damage, so flood coverage is a separate policy. source
Source: FEMA OpenFEMA NFIP policies. The premium excludes federal fees and surcharges; the figure with fees is FEMA's all-in policy cost. Policies are for the building and contents on FEMA's coverage mix, so this is not a quote.
Other coverage to know about in Ohio
- Mine subsidence in Ohio
- Ohio FAIR Plan, a FAIR plan
Frequently asked questions
How much is homeowners insurance in Carroll County, Ohio?
A typical ZIP code in Carroll County had a homeowners premium of about $1,139 a year, the median of 10 ZIP codes (U.S. Treasury Federal Insurance Office, 2022 data). Premiums have risen since then and vary by home, insurer and coverage, so a quote for your home will differ.
Does homeowners insurance cover flooding in Carroll County?
Most homeowners insurance does not cover flood damage, so flood coverage is a separate policy. FEMA reported 50 flood policies in force in Carroll County as of November 11, 2026, averaging $1,080 a year in premium ($1,369 with fees).
What if I cannot get homeowners insurance in Carroll County?
Ohio has one program for people who cannot find coverage in the private market: Ohio FAIR Plan. See the Ohio page for who can apply.
Sources
- NAIC homeowners insurance report (state average)
- U.S. Treasury Federal Insurance Office homeowners insurance data
- FEMA OpenFEMA NFIP policies
- floodsmart.gov
Each figure is shown with its source and year. Different sources are never combined into one number.
Ohio homeowners insurance → Carroll County closing costs → Carroll County property tax → Carroll County home buyer guide →
Advertisement
General information, not insurance advice. Confirm coverage, deductibles and eligibility with your insurer or the Ohio insurance department.
Carroll County overview