Indiana homeowners insurance

Updated

The average Indiana homeowners premium was $1,259 a year (National Association of Insurance Commissioners, 2023 data, HO-3 owner-occupied policies, all coverage ranges).

Read more

Premiums have risen since then and vary by home, insurer and coverage, so a quote for your home will differ.

What it costs here

The NAIC figure above is a statewide average for 2023, published July 2026. Insurers set prices by home, location and coverage, and the NAIC asks that state averages not be used to rank states, so this page does not. On the flood side, FEMA counted 13,324 National Flood Insurance Program policies in force in Indiana as of November 11, 2026.

Advertisement

Indiana homeowners insurance by county

The first figure is the median of the average premiums reported for each ZIP code in the county (Treasury Federal Insurance Office, 2022 data). It is a typical ZIP, not an average over every policy. The flood figures are federal flood policies in force.

Show all 92 counties
CountyTypical ZIP premium (Treasury, 2022)Flood policies in force (FEMA, November 11, 2026)Average flood cost with fees (FEMA)
Adams County$1,23743$1,128
Allen County$1,279517$1,549
Bartholomew County$1,416382$1,270
Benton County$1,486
Blackford County$1,3356$1,862
Boone County$1,577157$1,251
Brown County$1,76774$1,905
Carroll County$1,465175$1,774
Cass County$1,38182$1,307
Clark County$1,460652$1,112
Clay County$1,49030$1,298
Clinton County$1,45141$1,394
Crawford County$1,53117$1,872
Daviess County$1,46515$1,071
Dearborn County$1,57775$1,907
Decatur County$1,40023$1,532
DeKalb County$1,37154$1,352
Delaware County$1,436296$1,225
Dubois County$1,48142$1,840
Elkhart County$1,259359$1,247
Fayette County$1,33652$1,369
Floyd County$1,570160$2,994
Fountain County$1,5578$841
Franklin County$1,45932$1,687
Fulton County$1,52931$1,176
Gibson County$1,58229$840
Grant County$1,34467$1,565
Greene County$1,53455$1,382
Hamilton County$1,693503$1,288
Hancock County$1,758176$1,131
Harrison County$1,51271$2,055
Hendricks County$1,609135$1,279
Henry County$1,52958$1,773
Howard County$1,422137$1,281
Huntington County$1,44439$1,120
Jackson County$1,453152$1,214
Jasper County$1,454105$950
Jay County$1,34915$2,125
Jefferson County$1,44189$2,000
Jennings County$1,35521$1,713
Johnson County$1,617359$1,379
Knox County$1,54768$987
Kosciusko County$1,289432$773
LaGrange County$1,268160$803
Lake County$1,454870$1,273
LaPorte County$1,493133$1,123
Lawrence County$1,47130$1,666
Madison County$1,340193$1,309
Marion County$1,5452,115$1,284
Marshall County$1,37660$1,483
Martin County$1,3949$1,154
Miami County$1,39964$1,198
Monroe County$1,506167$1,545
Montgomery County$1,52635$1,686
Morgan County$1,649251$1,557
Newton County$1,54245$1,256
Noble County$1,336175$862
Ohio County$1,59329$1,142
Orange County$1,47940$3,082
Owen County$1,51843$1,799
Parke County$1,49418$1,512
Perry County$1,40343$1,791
Pike County$1,4719$2,339
Porter County$1,528110$1,120
Posey County$1,642104$1,144
Pulaski County$1,47355$1,285
Putnam County$1,56431$1,589
Randolph County$1,38957$970
Ripley County$1,52613$1,767
Rush County$1,50535$1,033
Scott County$1,52724$1,124
Shelby County$1,615186$1,208
Spencer County$1,51783$929
St. Joseph County$1,282230$1,008
Starke County$1,45752$832
Steuben County$1,304100$944
Sullivan County$1,5905$499
Switzerland County$1,37152$1,501
Tippecanoe County$1,414169$1,220
Tipton County$1,508120$1,214
Union County$1,3821$1,879
Vanderburgh County$1,439525$1,303
Vermillion County$1,51846$1,557
Vigo County$1,507523$1,259
Wabash County$1,41172$2,127
Warren County$1,5762$1,727
Warrick County$1,522115$1,277
Washington County$1,49313$1,971
Wayne County$1,34675$1,290
Wells County$1,34731$1,434
White County$1,390106$1,583
Whitley County$1,34062$857

Sources: Treasury FIO homeowners insurance data and FEMA OpenFEMA NFIP policies. Counties without a figure from either source are not listed. This list is alphabetical and is not a ranking.

Coverage you may need beyond a standard policy in Indiana

A standard homeowners policy does not cover everything. These are the extra coverages and rules that official Indiana and federal sources describe, each with its source.

Flood

Mine subsidence

Paying for homeowners insurance at closing

  • It is common for the buyer to pay the first year's homeowners insurance premium in advance at closing. consumerfinance.gov
  • The initial escrow deposit establishes the starting balance of the escrow account for taxes and insurance. consumerfinance.gov
  • Regulation X lets the servicer charge a cushion of no more than one-sixth (two months) of estimated total annual escrow payments. law.cornell.edu
  • Prepaid interest covers interest on the loan from the closing date to the end of that month. consumerfinance.gov

Indiana upfront cash at closing, with prepaids →

Where to get help in Indiana

Your state insurance department handles complaints and explains the rules for policies sold in Indiana: Indiana insurance regulator. Consumer help: homeowners insurance guidance.

Frequently asked questions

How much is homeowners insurance in Indiana?

The average Indiana homeowners premium (HO-3, owner-occupied) was $1,259 a year in 2023, per the National Association of Insurance Commissioners. Premiums have risen since then and vary by home, insurer and coverage, so a quote for your home will differ.

Does homeowners insurance cover floods in Indiana?

Most homeowners insurance does not cover flood damage, so flood coverage is a separate policy. FEMA reported 13,324 National Flood Insurance Program policies in force in Indiana as of November 11, 2026.

Do I need mine subsidence insurance in Indiana?

Indiana sources describe it this way: “standard policies do not cover mine subsidence claims.” Coverage: endorsement to homeowners policy via state program. Check your policy and ask your agent what applies to your home.

Sources

Premiums: NAIC, 2023 data. County figures: Treasury FIO, 2022 data. Flood policies: FEMA, as of November 11, 2026. Different sources and years are shown separately and never combined.

Advertisement

General information, not insurance advice. Confirm coverage, deductibles and eligibility with your insurer or the Indiana insurance department.

Homeowners insurance by state

More for Indiana