New York homeowners insurance

Updated

The average New York homeowners premium was $1,801 a year (National Association of Insurance Commissioners, 2023 data, HO-3 owner-occupied policies, all coverage ranges).

Read more

Premiums have risen since then and vary by home, insurer and coverage, so a quote for your home will differ.

What it costs here

The NAIC figure above is a statewide average for 2023, published July 2026. Insurers set prices by home, location and coverage, and the NAIC asks that state averages not be used to rank states, so this page does not. On the flood side, FEMA counted 142,303 National Flood Insurance Program policies in force in New York as of November 11, 2026.

Advertisement

New York homeowners insurance by county

The first figure is the median of the average premiums reported for each ZIP code in the county (Treasury Federal Insurance Office, 2022 data). It is a typical ZIP, not an average over every policy. The flood figures are federal flood policies in force.

Show all 62 counties
CountyTypical ZIP premium (Treasury, 2022)Flood policies in force (FEMA, November 11, 2026)Average flood cost with fees (FEMA)
Albany County$1,197583$1,740
Allegany County$860198$1,865
Bronx County$2,5942,786$1,285
Broome County$9531,337$1,993
Cattaraugus County$904386$1,836
Cayuga County$1,010265$1,775
Chautauqua County$949356$1,565
Chemung County$905400$1,082
Chenango County$1,046324$2,155
Clinton County$1,038145$1,648
Columbia County$2,054178$1,891
Cortland County$992225$2,388
Delaware County$1,270554$2,633
Dutchess County$1,9041,133$1,860
Erie County$1,0091,253$1,466
Essex County$1,215146$1,920
Franklin County$1,11075$2,108
Fulton County$1,00683$2,155
Genesee County$935204$1,881
Greene County$1,408355$2,373
Hamilton County$1,27045$1,957
Herkimer County$1,006297$1,788
Jefferson County$1,098250$1,452
Kings County$3,20116,923$958
Lewis County$1,09358$2,410
Livingston County$955196$1,451
Madison County$994292$1,999
Monroe County$9131,181$1,312
Montgomery County$1,108169$3,354
Nassau County$2,63434,356$1,787
New York County$10,33213,516$823
Niagara County$950429$1,315
Oneida County$1,034478$1,888
Onondaga County$9631,079$1,725
Ontario County$997292$1,797
Orange County$1,4931,454$1,561
Orleans County$94750$950
Oswego County$987256$1,483
Otsego County$1,065282$2,202
Putnam County$1,878251$1,435
Queens County$2,13916,180$1,280
Rensselaer County$1,192575$2,907
Richmond County$1,9875,322$1,213
Rockland County$1,7601,101$1,586
Saratoga County$1,117625$1,318
Schenectady County$1,135237$2,644
Schoharie County$1,154278$2,226
Schuyler County$94136$1,721
Seneca County$1,080111$1,306
St. Lawrence County$1,018109$1,633
Steuben County$917444$1,694
Suffolk County$2,69624,436$1,957
Sullivan County$1,507354$2,199
Tioga County$979572$2,488
Tompkins County$1,034369$2,733
Ulster County$1,487932$2,138
Warren County$1,297136$1,794
Washington County$1,210125$1,890
Wayne County$957152$1,685
Westchester County$2,5987,138$1,575
Wyoming County$94575$1,983
Yates County$1,086150$1,684

Sources: Treasury FIO homeowners insurance data and FEMA OpenFEMA NFIP policies. Counties without a figure from either source are not listed. This list is alphabetical and is not a ranking.

Coverage you may need beyond a standard policy in New York

A standard homeowners policy does not cover everything. These are the extra coverages and rules that official New York and federal sources describe, each with its source.

Flood

  • Protection for homeowners, renters and businesses. source

    “Insurance for flood damages is generally available under a separate policy issued through the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) and available to homeowners, renters and businesses.”

    How it is covered: Separate National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) policy.

    Program: National Flood Insurance Program (FloodSmart.gov)

  • Most homeowners insurance does not cover flood damage, so flood coverage is a separate policy. FEMA FloodSmart

    How it is covered: A separate National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) policy, or a private flood policy.

    Program: National Flood Insurance Program (FloodSmart.gov)

Hurricane and wind

  • Hurricane and wind deductibles are handled by DFS in claims. source

    “DFS can answer questions about agents, brokers and adjustors, the claims process (including hurricane and wind deductibles).”

    How it is covered: Hurricane/wind deductible in the homeowners policy.

    Program: NY DFS Homeowner and Tenant Resources

Insurers of last resort in New York

If you cannot find coverage in the private market, these programs may offer it.

Paying for homeowners insurance at closing

  • It is common for the buyer to pay the first year's homeowners insurance premium in advance at closing. consumerfinance.gov
  • The initial escrow deposit establishes the starting balance of the escrow account for taxes and insurance. consumerfinance.gov
  • Regulation X lets the servicer charge a cushion of no more than one-sixth (two months) of estimated total annual escrow payments. law.cornell.edu
  • Prepaid interest covers interest on the loan from the closing date to the end of that month. consumerfinance.gov

New York upfront cash at closing, with prepaids →

Where to get help in New York

Your state insurance department handles complaints and explains the rules for policies sold in New York: New York Department of Financial Services. Consumer help: homeowners insurance guidance.

Frequently asked questions

How much is homeowners insurance in New York?

The average New York homeowners premium (HO-3, owner-occupied) was $1,801 a year in 2023, per the National Association of Insurance Commissioners. Premiums have risen since then and vary by home, insurer and coverage, so a quote for your home will differ.

Does homeowners insurance cover floods in New York?

Most homeowners insurance does not cover flood damage, so flood coverage is a separate policy. FEMA reported 142,303 National Flood Insurance Program policies in force in New York as of November 11, 2026.

Do I need hurricane or wind insurance in New York?

New York sources describe it this way: “DFS can answer questions about agents, brokers and adjustors, the claims process (including hurricane and wind deductibles).” Coverage: hurricane/wind deductible in the homeowners policy. Check your policy and ask your agent what applies to your home.

What is New York Property Insurance Underwriting Association (NYPIUA)?

New York Property Insurance Underwriting Association (NYPIUA) is a state property insurance pool. What it covers: dwellings, commercial buildings and personal property.

Sources

Premiums: NAIC, 2023 data. County figures: Treasury FIO, 2022 data. Flood policies: FEMA, as of November 11, 2026. Different sources and years are shown separately and never combined.

Advertisement

General information, not insurance advice. Confirm coverage, deductibles and eligibility with your insurer or the New York insurance department.

Homeowners insurance by state

More for New York